Thursday, 21 October 2010

Dividing the Frame

I'm just reading the course material on this topic. I thought I'd quickly comment on the two photographs at the foot of page 39. I'll start with the second one, White Branches, Mono Lake by Ansel Adams, which I love. It certainly illustrates horizontal division of the frame, with the lake taking approximately 50% of the frame and the shore, with its white driftwood branches, the remainder. But it's interesting to consider what the image would have been like without the white driftwood. Doubtless it would have rendered the image substantially less interesting, with nothing in particular to demand our attention. The driftwood works in two ways; its position in the foreground breaks the static feel that the image would otherwise have had, but its brilliant white colour also adds a strong contrast and really draws the eye. Excellent.

The first image, Salisbury Plain by Edwin Smith, initially had little impact on me and I wasn't even clear why it had been chosen as an example of dividing the frame. But after repeated viewings, it suddenly became very clear and revealed to me how rigid my expectations of composition must be (this must change!). The frame is of course divided diagonally, with the farm straddling the centre line. The diagonal line which further divides the top left hand triangular region adds further interest and as it reaches down to the top of the farm building, our eye is encouraged even more to focus on the foreground.

Saturday, 2 October 2010

Exercise : Balance




I'm not convinced I fully understand this as I may be about to demonstrate! Some of the examples in the course material are crystal clear. But for any other OCA TAOP students who might happen upon my blog, I must confess I'm really not sure about the photograph of the farmhouse on page 38. Hmmmm.



Anyway, I had a go at the exercise and have drawn boundaries around the elements which contribute to the balance (or imbalance) of the following size previously taken photographs. Comments welcome.
















































Red Door

The wires which cross the door natually divide the shot into four quarters. But there's another source of balance, that of the door handle in the top left, and a smaller dark shadow in the bottom right.

Tree and Cloud

The balance in this shot is predominantly due to the large white cloud moving in from the top left of the image to the centre, dominating the shot, and the smaller tree in the bottom right. The way the tree leans and the cloud seems to move adds a sense of dynamics to the balance too.

Fence and Nails

The balance in this shot is a consequence of the simply symmettry about the vertical line of the fence panels.

Squash

There's a symmetry about the horizontal line dividing the two halfs of the squash. But there's also an imbalance due to the positioning of the squash over the left hand side of the frame.

Monster face

The balance here is once again due to the rough symmetry about a vertical line dividing the shot in two.

Hang Glider and Trees

I'm glad I chose to think about the balance in this shot! It's a bit extreme due to the amount of empty space in the image, but there's balance there due to the trees in the far bottom left hand corner, the largest element in the shot, and the tiny hang glider way up in the top right hand corner.

Zorbital




Three photographs taken near Brighton on a day out to give "zorbing" a try. I really like the simplicity of the second image. But I just don't know what to make of the third! In terms of "dividing the frame", "balance" and other compositional ideas, what on earth is this one about? Is this good or bad? It's kind of extreme.... mostly empty and I'm hoping it holds a surprise... that when the eye eventually spots the hang glider in the top right hand corner, the empty space suddenly has a purpose in the shot. File under "experiment" I guess.


























Zorbs and Flags



Green and Blue



Empty Space?



Cobwebs



The hedge in front of my house was *covered* in dewy cobwebs a couple of mornings ago so I grabbed my camera...... click the image to see all 4 selected shots.