Thursday, 21 October 2010

Dividing the Frame

I'm just reading the course material on this topic. I thought I'd quickly comment on the two photographs at the foot of page 39. I'll start with the second one, White Branches, Mono Lake by Ansel Adams, which I love. It certainly illustrates horizontal division of the frame, with the lake taking approximately 50% of the frame and the shore, with its white driftwood branches, the remainder. But it's interesting to consider what the image would have been like without the white driftwood. Doubtless it would have rendered the image substantially less interesting, with nothing in particular to demand our attention. The driftwood works in two ways; its position in the foreground breaks the static feel that the image would otherwise have had, but its brilliant white colour also adds a strong contrast and really draws the eye. Excellent.

The first image, Salisbury Plain by Edwin Smith, initially had little impact on me and I wasn't even clear why it had been chosen as an example of dividing the frame. But after repeated viewings, it suddenly became very clear and revealed to me how rigid my expectations of composition must be (this must change!). The frame is of course divided diagonally, with the farm straddling the centre line. The diagonal line which further divides the top left hand triangular region adds further interest and as it reaches down to the top of the farm building, our eye is encouraged even more to focus on the foreground.

Saturday, 2 October 2010

Exercise : Balance




I'm not convinced I fully understand this as I may be about to demonstrate! Some of the examples in the course material are crystal clear. But for any other OCA TAOP students who might happen upon my blog, I must confess I'm really not sure about the photograph of the farmhouse on page 38. Hmmmm.



Anyway, I had a go at the exercise and have drawn boundaries around the elements which contribute to the balance (or imbalance) of the following size previously taken photographs. Comments welcome.
















































Red Door

The wires which cross the door natually divide the shot into four quarters. But there's another source of balance, that of the door handle in the top left, and a smaller dark shadow in the bottom right.

Tree and Cloud

The balance in this shot is predominantly due to the large white cloud moving in from the top left of the image to the centre, dominating the shot, and the smaller tree in the bottom right. The way the tree leans and the cloud seems to move adds a sense of dynamics to the balance too.

Fence and Nails

The balance in this shot is a consequence of the simply symmettry about the vertical line of the fence panels.

Squash

There's a symmetry about the horizontal line dividing the two halfs of the squash. But there's also an imbalance due to the positioning of the squash over the left hand side of the frame.

Monster face

The balance here is once again due to the rough symmetry about a vertical line dividing the shot in two.

Hang Glider and Trees

I'm glad I chose to think about the balance in this shot! It's a bit extreme due to the amount of empty space in the image, but there's balance there due to the trees in the far bottom left hand corner, the largest element in the shot, and the tiny hang glider way up in the top right hand corner.

Zorbital




Three photographs taken near Brighton on a day out to give "zorbing" a try. I really like the simplicity of the second image. But I just don't know what to make of the third! In terms of "dividing the frame", "balance" and other compositional ideas, what on earth is this one about? Is this good or bad? It's kind of extreme.... mostly empty and I'm hoping it holds a surprise... that when the eye eventually spots the hang glider in the top right hand corner, the empty space suddenly has a purpose in the shot. File under "experiment" I guess.


























Zorbs and Flags



Green and Blue



Empty Space?



Cobwebs



The hedge in front of my house was *covered* in dewy cobwebs a couple of mornings ago so I grabbed my camera...... click the image to see all 4 selected shots.

Sunday, 19 September 2010

National Portrait Gallery

Just signed up for their newsletter so I can keep an eye open for exhibitions :-)

Panayiotis Lamprou in The Guardian

I just read this week's photography feature in The Guardian. It's about a particularly intimate and "difficult" photograph by Panayiotis Lamprou which is short-listed for the Taylor Wessing Photographic Portrait Prize.


The full article is here:

http://www.guardian.co.uk/artanddesign/2010/sep/17/panayiotis-lamprou-portrait-wife-photography#

I have to say I've been left unsure as to just what I think about the photograph. It's so intimate and private a moment that it left me feeling like an intruder... very uneasy indeed.

The article goes on to raise more general questions about photography versus voyeurism, exploitation and even pornography. Just where is the proverbial line drawn, we are asked to consider? And I simply don't know the answer except to consider that the answer depends largely on who is looking at the image and perhaps to an extent, what the photographers motivation was when the image was captured.

The article also mentions the National Portrait Gallery though which reminds me that I really must get there one of these days. The Photographer of Modern Life exhibition looks worth a trip into London: http://www.npg.org.uk/index.php

Exercise : Focal Length and Different Viewpoints

This was a surprisingly educational exercise! All that was required here was to find an image which had elements receding into the distance and then photograph it twice, the first time from a certain distance but zoomed in as near as possible so that the image was tight against the frame and the second time, selecting the same tight framing but instead of zooming in, zoom right out to the widest angle and walk physically closer until the image was positioned in the frame in the same way.

So in theory, zooming in and moving physically closer will give the same result, right? Wrong! I really had never thought about this before and so probably was harbouring this completely false idea without realising it. The point of this exercise was to reveal to the student photographer (me) just how different the two approaches to a shot can be. The course material points out that the relative size of objects receding into the distance does not vary in the same way whan you are zoomed right in. We expect more distant objects of the same physical size to look smaller than those closer to us. And this is the case even when zoomed in, but the degree to which more distance objects look smaller is significantly lessened when zoomed in. Also, I found that angles changed when I moved physically closer to an object rather than zoomed in. And other issues changed the photo too. I tried to take some photographs of the balconies at the front of a fairly large building. When I moved physically closer, the angle between the ground and the top-most part of my photograph got more obtuse.... I had to point the camera up to keep the upper most part of the shot in the frame. This had a substantial effect on the photograph. There were physical problems too..... when I walked backwards away from one shot, to take the wide-angled version, I found that I had been walking downhill due to the way the path sloped and this of course also changed the perspective.

Lesson: zooming in and moving physically closer are not the same thing at all!

Photographs? Oh, they were all really horrible and have been deleted! But lesson learned and that was the aim :-)

Sunday, 12 September 2010

Exercise: Focal lengths

The objective of this exercise was simply to photograph a scene a number of times, varying the focal length at each shot so that we can see the effect of transitioning from the shortest focal length (widest angle) to the longest focal length (narrowest angle). I have a 24-70mm zoom lense and so worked my way from 24mm to 70mm.

This was not a very interesting exercise... and I think my uninteresting, lacklustre photographs unfortunately reflect this. Anyway, click on the thumbnail index to the left to go to the images themselves and browse away. At the foot of each image, you can see the focal length and the exposure details.

Friday, 10 September 2010

Exercise: A sequence of composition




This week's exercise is a kind of "stream of consciousness" for photographers. The idea is to photograph all those images which you would normally mentally reject whilst assessing a scene for the image you will eventually choose to capture. So censorship is "off" and we get to see what passes through the photographer's mind in the lead up to taking that final photograph. Furthermore, the exercise asked that a scene involving people be used. As such, I went to a market in South London on a weekend where by chance there happened to be a festival of "alternative culture" on and this included bands as well as the usual market stalls. It turned out to be a good choice and I came away with literally hundreds of photographs and 6 sequences for the exercise.



So how did it go? Well I have to say this exercise was a thousand times more challenging than any of the other exercises I've done so far. First of all, it involved people! And I rarely photograph people. I don't feel enormously comfortable photographing people and don't like having my own photograph taken. Luckily, I have a friend who is an avid photographer of people and he had advised me to talk to people, explain what I was doing and check it was OK to photograph them before proceeding. And this worked very well. I generally showed my OCA student card, explained I was doing a photography course and with only one exception, people were very happy for me to photograph them. Some people carried on as if I wasn't there and some posed a little :-) Either way, I owe a big thank you to everyone who let me photograph them and a feeble apology if, after all that fuss, your photograph didn't make it into my learning log.



Other ways in which the exercise was challenging were as follows; firstly, just selecting a scene from amongst the many possible locations and activities that were going on a round me took some thought. Once a scene had been selected, the primary issue was that it kept changing of course! And all this is happening with your eye to the view finder so you need to concentrate, really seeing what is in the view finder and making quick decisions about image capture, camera settings, focus and so on, all the time. On the technical side, there were times when I wished I had a decent telephoto lense as with my humble 24-70mm lense, I had to be much closer to the subjects than was perhaps ideal at times.



So here are the six sequences of photographs I've opted to publish in my learning log for this exercise. In all cases, the "final" image is shown here in the log. To browse through the sequence from start to finish, click the image and this will bring up a page with the whole sequence laid out as thumbnails. Click the thumbnail in the top left of the page and then use the Next link to step through the sequence one at a time. Images generally have captions which explain my thinking about each step. Oh, and the band are "A Terrible Splendour" by the way :-)
















































Sequence 1 : Synth Player


Click above for the full image sequence

Sequence 2 : Singer


Click above for the full image sequence

Sequence 3 : Lady in red (shoes)


Click above for the full image sequence

Sequence 4 : Monster


Click above for the full image sequence

Sequence 5 : Military Man


Click above for the full image sequence

Sequence 6 : Market Stall


Click above for the full image sequence

Sunday, 5 September 2010

Theatre


Whilst at the Edinburgh Fringe, I had the opportunity to photograph a play. This was a relatively new photographic challenge; indoors, with "unfriendly" lighting and no flash photography permitted. So from a technical point of view this meant ISO1600 (the most sensitive setting on my camera), f2.8 and trying really hard to avoid camera shake! From a composition point of view it was a chance to think about framing although the limited zoom capability of my lense was a constraint here. Either way, I'm quite pleased with the results. There's a bit of blurring on some of the images, where there was movement on stage, but I think the blurring works in a positive way, adding a dynamic feel to the images. As usual, click on the image to go to the photos.

Wednesday, 1 September 2010

Exercise: Object in different positions in the frame


In this exercise, a number of shots of a simple object (a rusty old bucket) with a simple, fairly bland background (my excuse of a lawn) have been taken with the object in a variety of positions in the frame. Click on the image to go to the site which hosts them and browse through.

The first was taken with little thought and just centres the object. The others experiment with placing the bucket a little off centre, in top and bottom corners and over to one side.

With this particular object and background, I think the last shot, with the bucket in the bottom right hand corner works best. Being in the bottom right it is also nearer to the camera, more in the foreground whilst still allowing the background to appear "whole". I like the centred shot the least. It elliminates the background through seeming to completely interrupt its contribution to the image. The slightly off centre image works a little better though.

Tuesday, 24 August 2010

Squash!

The squash which formed the main subject of the last exercise was put to good use in a couple of meals. It had such great colour, I couldn't resist photographing it after it had been sliced open. Click the image to the left to browse.

Exercise: Fitting the frame to the subject : Croppings


The final part of the exercise involved experimenting with a variety of alternate croppings. I chose the shot which had been taken with "no thought", which is the 3rd photo in the first collection as my subject. The croppings I produced can be viewed by clicking the image to the left. This exercise made quite a powerful impression. Hopefully the selected croppings convey the impact which cropping (and therefore the act of selecting the content of your frame) can have on the same subject.

Exercise: Fitting the frame to the subject


This exercise required 4 or more photographs of a subject, with the frame more or less tight around the subject. I got a little carried away and seem to have experimented with the position within the frame too, which is the objective of the next exercise :-)

The primary subect is intended to be the squash with the green apples and purple beans forming background colour and texture.

Click the image to the left to go to the collection of shots. They're not in any particular order.

Sunday, 15 August 2010

Exercise: Panning and Shutter Speeds


This exercise required a series of images of moving objects, with the camera panning to track the object, hopefully resulting in a crisp version of the main subject, with any blurring affecting only the background. The series of images are on my woolleyworld web site so click the image to the left to go there now.

I like the image taken at 1/60 sec at f / 8.0 best. The car has retained its sharpness but the background is quite blurred, giving quite an impression of speed. The photos which used slower shutter speeds all resulted in the car being increasingly blurred. So 1/60 was the slowest speed where my panning was able to maintain the sharp car image whilst giving a substantially blurred background and therefore, taken in combination, the best overall impression of speed.


But there's more. You can probably sense the tension in these photographs.... a palpable sense of *danger*. This is because partway into the shoot, I got questioned by an off duty policeman on his way to work! It went like this:

After about 15 minutes of shooting, a car coming the opposite way to my subjects and therefore behind me (and therefore not being photographed!), pulls over (difficult on this fast road) and parks on the curb with his hazzard lights on. A guy gets out and strides towards me and pulls a badge and beckons me to approach! Oh dear.

So I approached, had a look at the badge and sure enough he was po-leees.

"What are you doing, mate?" Stern, not at all friendly tone.

Glancing down at large camera around my neck in an obvious way: "I'm taking photographs".

Pause.

Slight facial twitch.

"Why?"

"I'm doing a photography course and have to take photographs of moving objects"

Pause.

Disapponted look.... realisation he won't be taking me to the cells ... he needs a bit more than that.
"Well I don't like to have my photograph taken on the way to work"

"It's kind of hard to ask permission".

Pause.

Stare.

Strides off away from me back to his car.

And I took his photo as he left!





OK, so not my best photo! I was under pressure, not using the view finder and with shutter speed slooooooow from my previous shot. Excuses!

The things we do for a photo :-)

Saturday, 14 August 2010

Exercise: Shutter speeds

For this exercise I took a series of shots of a swinging lantern, taking care to start the lantern swinging from the same height each time. It was a dull day with very poor light so the fastest shutter speed I was able to use was 1/800 sec at f / 2.8. The slowest I shot with before the images became over-exposed was 1/5 sec at f / 22. The image started to lose sharpness at about 1/320 sec at f / 3.5 and was an unrecognisable blur at 1/5 sec at f / 22. The full set can be browsed at this URL: http://woolleyworld.woolleynet.com/aop/exercise_shutter_speeds/index.html or just click the image to the left.

Click one of the thumbnails for a larger image which is annotated with the exposure and then use the next and previous links.

Tuesday, 3 August 2010

Project: Focus. Exercise: Focus at different apertures


Three photographs of the same scene, each at a different aperture

























1/5 sec at f/2.8





13/10 sec at f/8.0





10 sec at f/22


The following versions have been modified to show the region which is in focus
























1/5 sec at f/2.8





13/10 sec at f/8.0





10 sec at f/22

Sunday, 1 August 2010

Beach

Some shots from a beach. All of them are about texture and pattern and colour and contrast. The contrast comes from the materials depicted... stone, sand and seaweed as well as the contrasting physical textures and colours.






Project: Focus. Exercise: Focus with a set aperture

This exercise required three photographs of the same scene to be taken, but with the three shots focusing at different distances. I arranged three guitars in a staggered fashion, behind each other and took three shots with a shallow depth of field (f2.8), focusing first on the most distant guitar, then on the middle guitar and finally on the guitar nearest to me. Here they are:







1. Focusing on the most distant guitar


















2. Focusing on the middle guitar

















3. Focusing on the nearest guitar














I like the first and third images best. The third is the most "obvious" shot in that I would tend to expect the object in the foreground of a photograph to be the focus of the image. I'm comfortable with having my eye drawn to the nearest object and like that I can see the guitar's features in detail, with the "lesser" guitars tailing off into the distance.

But I also really like the first shot, with the most distant guitar in focus. This shot "surprises" me in that it goes against my expectations of having the foreground in focus. I love the way it picks out that distant guitar and demands that I look at it.

This is a technique I will aim to use. I find the idea that I can control to some degree, the attention of the viewer, compelling. Picking out a face from a crowd is an obvious scenario where this technique could work well.

Thursday, 29 July 2010

Exercise: Focal length and angle of view

I wasn't familiar with the term "Standard focal length" which I encountered in this exercise. It means the focal length (and therefore angle of view) at which the image appears similar to the way it is seen by the unaided human eye. On my camera with its 24-70mm zoom lens this appears to be at about 60mm.

I also liked the image in the material which showed a scene where the camera had focused on a distant object and, due to the shallow depth of field, the foreground was out of focus so that the eye is drawn immediately to the distant object in the top of the frame. Must try this technique!

Project: Getting to know your camera

I did this "project" tonight. Reading through my camera's manual did remind me of some things I'd forgotten;

  • How to switch between different auto-focus points
  • About the different auto-focus modes
  • How to use the depth of field preview function
I was also reminded of a useful rule of thumb to avoid blurred images due to camera shake. If the shutter speed is less than the reciprocal of the focal length x 1.6 then there's a risk of camera shake affecting the image (so use a tripod or increase the ISO). Uses 2.0 instead of 1.6 makes the mental arithmetic easier of course!

Monday, 26 July 2010

Friends and Flowers


I spent this weekend at an annual get together of old school friends known affectionately as "MarFest". I took my camera along and had the opportunity to take photos of flowers at a local organic garden centre and of the assembled friends in the evening using flash. The flowers were an excellent subject though only a small fraction of the photos came close to doing them justice. The photos of friends were just for fun.... flash photography is a new subject fror me and harder than it looks, especially when outside with no walls or ceiling to reflect the light. So, nothing here I'm particular excited by but all practice is good and this year I intend to take every opportunity I can to practice and experiment.

See http://woolleyworld.woolleynet.com/events/2010_07_24_marfest/index.html

Sunday, 18 July 2010

Photo 10 - Half green


This is clearly an image of two halves and of light and dark. There's a kind of symmetry at work two, with each half containing a nail and a crack in the surface. The lighter green and gray contrast well with the darker gray and green.

Photo 9 - Dead Leaves on Brickwork


The leaves and brickwork consist of complimentary browns and reds. The mortar divides the image into regions and the leaves draw the eye, acting as a kind of visual centre of gravity.

Photo 8 - Cloud Landing on Tree


I think this image is about movement... .despite it being an image of a quite still scene. The cloud looks like it is coming into land on top of the tree, which is bending away from the approaching cloud.

I'm not sure what to think about the colours here. I think it would perhaps have been a more striking image if the tree and the ground it is growing from had been quite black and the cloud a little whiter.

Photo 7 - Sea, Sky, Chalk, Grass


Photos 1 and 2 are images which consist roughly of three 'triangular' regions and so does this one. The lighter region of sky in the top left of the image and the sea, bordered by the beach, form a lighter, wedge shaped region which converges at the cliffs. It's interesting to me that it has this structure.... I'd never noticed this is any of the images selected here before undertaking this exercise. Aside from this, colour plays an important role here, with the brilliant white of the cliffs and beach making for a striking central element.

Photo 6 - Gold and Green


I really like this image. It's much harder to pigeon hole other than to say that it's "abstract". What it is actually doesn't matter and in fact not knowing for sure what it is is an important in that it removes knowledge and preconceptions from the experience and you're just left to appreciate (in some way) the image for what it is; a patterned, textured, coloured surface, with regions of gold contrasting with regions of a variety of green shades.

Photo 5 - Red Metal Door


I suppose the colour red might have some part to play in this image :-) But structurally, the cross-wire is key; it divides the image into 4 quarters and its shadow gives an impression of depth on what would otherwise have been a more or less flat image. The weathered paint, with its dimples and bubbles provides an interesting texture too.

Photo 4 - Grey Blue Metal


This image is about colour and shade and about repetition of simple shapes. I love the bluey grey of these crude metal *things* (I have no idea what they are except that they're some kind of tool which you probably mount on a wooden handle) and the crude repetitive pattern.

Photo 3 - Terracotta Ground


This one is very different to Photos 1 and 2. This one is all about colour and texture. The earthy tones of the ground and the violets of the petals work well together. I know nothing about the 'rules' of colour that apply to photography yet so it will be interesting to see if there's anything in the course that would explain why these colours are pleasing when placed together like this.

Broadly speaking there are two different textures here; the first being that of the soil and dust and the second, a rougher texture produced by the dry grass collected in an island in the centre of the image. It really does look like an island in a terracotta sea.

The twigs lying in a kind of zig-zag formation do break the image up and perhaps bring a degree of loose structure to the image.

Photo 2 - Boy on a Quiet Beach


This image is quite similar to Photo 1 in a way. It also has three roughly triangular regions and two lines which converge to meet on the right hand side of the image. The main region and its two converging lines are created by the brighter area of sky on the left and its reflection in the water and wet sand. The lines bordering this region converge on the main subject, the boy. I like the symmetry brought about by the reflection and the fact that this is more or less a gray scale image with little colour. This suits the quietness of the image. I do wish it wasn't quite so under-exposed though!

Photo 1 - Empty Winter Street


There are two curves in this image which start at the left and sweep across and converge at the right. The first follows the tops of the lights and the second the curve of the road. I think this is an important aspect of the structure of this image. It more or less divides the image into three triangular regions (albeit triangles with curved sides). The 'main' triangle with its base as the left hand side of the photo is well lit and the other two less well lit.

I like the colour produced by the sodium street lights and the way it has tinted everything in the shot. The image has a lonely, empty feel to it. I like the absence of people and the contrast with the man-made elements of the scene (the road, the lights).