I'm just looking at these two images in the section entitled Theories of Frame Division. My natural and immediate reaction to the two images, with no conscious analysis was interesting (to me at least!). I *love* The Bicycle. And I really do not like Untitled.
Understanding why I reacted this way probably holds some important lessons for me but right now I don't feel I know enough to be able to say with certainty or clarity. What I can say is that Paul Strand's image has a number of elements I think I can recognise as contributing to my overall assessment:
1. It *perhaps* uses the golden section or rule of thirds. The bicycle itself is positioned somewhere near to the intersection of both the horizontal and vertical lines which divide the frame into the left hand third and the bottom third.
2. The vertical pillar and constrasting darkness to the right and light to the left seems to divide the frame into two almost unrelated parts.
3. The sweeping arc of the stairs provides a surprising continuity, bridging the dark half with the light half as it reaches up towards the final section of the stairs to the left of the image.
4. There's a dark rectangle to the top right and I suspect this sits roughly at an intersection between horizontal and vertical "third lines". The rule of thirds again?
5. And finally there's the question of balance. I think there are two pairs of visual counterweights at work here. The top right small, dark rectangular area balances the larger rectangular area which contains the bicycle at the bottom left and which is bordered by the vertical pillar and the top of the wallpaper. Similarly, the light, small rectangualr region which contains the top part of the stairs balances the larger rectangle at the bottom right which contains the bottom patr of the stairs.
William Klein's image on the other hand bothers me because my eye just doesn't know where to look and I find myself moving my focus from point to point continually. There are three areas of focus which seem to compete for my attention; the man, the statue and the scooter. I have to say I'm also not keen on the fact that the horizontal wooden beam set into the wall above the man's head is not properly horizontal to the image frame.
No comments:
Post a Comment