The first part of this exercise required 4-6 images, each of which was deliberately under-exposed or over-exposed. For this exercise I set my camera to its "evaluative metering" setting which results in normal exposure being calculated based on an average of the brightness across the whole frame.To achieve over or under exposure, I used the camera's exposure compensation feature.
Overall I was quite surprised by this exercise. In many cases I deliberately photographed what I believed to be bright surfaces, expecting normal exposure to therefore darken lighter colours and for me to respond by adjusting the exposure in the positive direction, thus lightening the result and ensuring the resulting exposure looked the way I wanted it to. But what I found was that the normal exposure version was often brighter than I expected so that light areas were a little harsh and detail was lost from areas both dark and light. Looking carefully at these images, I think the fact is that the bright areas command your attention when photographing so that you end up with a skewed idea about the proportions of light and dark in the image. In fact in all cases there was more dark than I had recognised at the time of taking the photograph.
In the following, the image which has normal exposure is shown to the left and adjacent to that is the under or over exposed version which I have chosen. In each case I follow with some comments on my choice.
Image 1 - Dying Sunflower (+1/3)
|
|
This is a high contrast image with the image more or less split in two around a diagonal line running from the top right to the bottom left. The bottom right region is very dark whilst the top left is back lit against a bright near-white wall and with bright sunshine shining directly on the upper surface of the leaf. The bright region seems to have caused the automatically derived normal exposure to be a little too dark, so that a lot of detail from the darker region has been lost. Adjusting the exposure by +1/3 has recovered some of that detail without over-exposing.
|
Image 2 - Green Tomatoes (-1/3)
|
 |
There are quite dark shades of green across the whole frame so normal exposure had slightly lightened the image. I wanted to retain the rich, saturated darker greens so under-exposed by -1/3. The reflections on the surface of the tomatoes created a slightly harsh over exposed effect which was lessened in the selected under-exposed version.
|
Image 3 - Water droplets on car headlight (-2/3)
|
|
Normal exposure seemed too bright and to have lost the contrast between the dark underside of droplets and the lighter upper surfaces. This is presumably because overall there is more dark than light elements and the evaluative metering therefore produced a normal exposure which was lighter overall. My chosen version is under-exposed by -2/3 and has significantly improved the contrast and impact of the darker areas.
|
Image 4 - Water droplets on car body (-1)
|
|
Normal exposure seemed too bright and to have lost the contrast between the dark underside of droplets and the lighter upper surfaces. This is presumably because overall there is more dark than light elements and the evaluative metering therefore produced a normal exposure which was lighter overall.
|
Image 5 - Car wing mirror (-2/3)
|
|
Normal exposure has over-exposed the upper white surface which is the primary area of interest. Reducing exposure by 2/3 has restored detail and contrast in that surface whilst doing no "harm" to the dark underside. Normal exposure was presumably determined in this way because overall there is more dark than light elements and the evaluative metering therefore produced a normal exposure which was lighter overall. This surprised me as I was expecting the bright white upper surface to dominate, producing a darker than required normal exposure which I would have had to compensate for in the opposite direction!
|
Image 6 - Car surface with bright and dark region (-2/3)
|
|
Once again I was surprised to find myself selecting an artificially under-exposed version of this shot. I had expected the brighter region (caused by sunlight reflecting in the car's wing mirror) to have the most dominant effect on the exposure calculation, thus giving me a darker than I might have wanted exposure, leading me to compensate by making it brighter. Bit in fact once again the opposite has happened. The issue here is that on viewing the results, I was very drawn to the water droplets in the darker region. Under exposing has improved the contrast once again and the droplets in the shadowed region have excellent definition now due to their own undersides and small shadows being stronger.
|
No comments:
Post a Comment